The best-looking pitcher we have tested, with a long-life filter and a genuinely fast pour, for the price of a plain jug. Just know that as shipped it is a chlorine and taste filter, not a certified lead or PFAS filter.
We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never affects our scores.
A gorgeous, long-life taste pitcher, with an asterisk on protection
The Chubby is the pitcher people actually want to leave on the table. The retro shape and wooden handle look far more expensive than the roughly $30 it costs, it pours fast (a full reservoir in under three minutes in independent testing, well ahead of most jugs), and the filter lasts an unusually long time: about 200 gallons, or two to three months, roughly five times a standard Brita cartridge. That longevity keeps running cost near $0.07 a gallon. It also leaves beneficial minerals in the water, so the result tastes clean rather than flat, and it knocks out about 97% of chlorine.
Where you need to read carefully is what it is certified to do. The filter it ships with is certified to NSF/ANSI 42 (chlorine, taste, and odor) and NSF/ANSI 372 (lead-free materials). It is not NSF 53 certified for lead, and its heavy-metal and PFAS reduction are manufacturer claims, not independent certifications. That matters on a health purchase: if your reason for buying a filter is lead or forever chemicals, the standard Chubby does not certify that job. The good news is there is a fix. Waterdrop sells an upgraded PF01A-P filter, certified to NSF 53, 42, and 372, that drops into the same pitcher and adds certified reduction of lead, cadmium, copper, and mercury. Treat the Chubby as a beautiful taste pitcher by default, and a certified metals pitcher only once you fit that filter.
Best for: renters and design-minded buyers on decent municipal water who mainly want better taste, less chlorine, and a pitcher that looks good, at rock-bottom running cost. If lead or PFAS is the reason you are shopping, fit the upgraded NSF 53 filter or choose a certified pitcher.
How it scored, category by category
Each category is weighted into the overall score. Contaminant reduction carries the most weight, and the standard filter’s narrow certified scope is what holds the Chubby back. Its filter life, ease, and pour speed are genuinely excellent.
What it removes
We separate what the standard filter is independently certified to do from what Waterdrop markets. The distinction is the whole story with this pitcher.
| Contaminant | Standard filter | Certified? |
|---|---|---|
| Chlorine, taste & odor | ~97% | NSF 42 |
| Lead-free materials | Yes | NSF 372 |
| Lead | Reduced (claim) | Not on standard filter |
| PFOA / PFOS (PFAS) | Reduced (claim) | Not certified |
| Cadmium, copper, mercury | Reduced (claim) | Upgrade filter only |
| Limescale / hardness | Reduced (claim) | Not certified |
The standard WD-PF-01A filter is certified to NSF/ANSI 42 (chlorine, taste, odor) and 372 (lead-free materials). Its lead, heavy-metal, and PFAS reduction are manufacturer claims, not NSF 53 certifications. The upgraded Waterdrop PF01A-P filter is certified to NSF 53, 42, and 372, adding certified reduction of lead, cadmium, copper, and mercury in the same pitcher. If lead or forever chemicals are your concern, see our lead guide and PFAS guide, and use a certified filter.
Pros and cons
What we liked
- Genuinely handsome retro design with a wooden handle
- Very long 200-gallon filter life and low cost per gallon
- Fast pour, easy setup, and it keeps beneficial minerals
- Certified chlorine reduction, and an NSF 53 upgrade filter exists
Worth considering
- Standard filter is NSF 42/372 only, not certified for lead
- Heavy-metal and PFAS reduction are claims, not certifications
- Two-shade replacement indicator confuses new owners
- Slightly wide for some refrigerator door shelves
What actual owners report
Our score reflects certified performance. Owner sentiment, summarized from verified buyer and independent long-term reviews, is warm on looks and taste, with a few practical niggles.
Owners love how it looks and how quickly it pours, and most are happy with the taste and the long gaps between filter changes. The recurring gripes are small: a confusing change indicator and a footprint that does not always fit a fridge door.
Owners consistently praise
- The elegant retro design and wooden handle
- Fast filtering and clean, not-flat taste
- How rarely the long-life filter needs changing
Common complaints
- The two-shade replacement light is confusing
- A touch wide for some refrigerator door shelves
- Marketing claims outrun what the standard filter certifies
Qualitative summary of recurring themes across verified buyer and independent long-term reviews, current as of August 2026. We report the patterns we see, positive and negative, and never cherry-pick.
The details
Common questions
Does the Waterdrop Chubby remove lead?
Not as it ships. The standard WD-PF-01A filter is certified to NSF/ANSI 42 and 372, which covers chlorine, taste, and lead-free materials, but not certified lead reduction; Waterdrop only claims heavy-metal reduction on that filter. For certified lead, fit the upgraded PF01A-P filter (NSF 53) or choose a certified-lead pitcher like the PUR PLUS or Brita Elite. See our lead guide.
How long does the filter last?
About 200 gallons, or two to three months for a typical household, roughly five times a standard Brita cartridge. That keeps running cost near $0.07 a gallon, among the lowest of any pitcher. Just watch the change indicator: owners find its two shades of red confusing, so note the date you installed it as a backup.
Is it just a better-looking Brita?
In some ways, yes: it looks nicer, the filter lasts far longer, it pours faster, and it keeps minerals. But the standard Brita Elite is NSF 53 certified for lead, which the standard Chubby is not. Pick the Chubby for design and taste on good water; pick Brita, or the Chubby’s upgrade filter, if certified lead reduction matters.
Does it remove PFAS?
The standard filter claims PFOA and PFOS reduction but is not NSF certified for it. The upgraded PF01A-P filter adds NSF 53 certification. For reliable, certified PFAS removal, a reverse-osmosis system like the AquaTru Carafe is the safer choice; see our PFAS guide for the certified shortlist.
Should you buy it?
Buy the Chubby if you want the nicest-looking pitcher on the counter, better-tasting water with the chlorine taken out, and a filter you rarely have to change, all for around $30. On those terms it is excellent and cheap to run. Go in clear-eyed, though: as shipped it is a taste pitcher, certified for chlorine and lead-free materials but not for lead or PFAS. If those contaminants are your concern, fit the upgraded NSF 53 filter, step up to a certified pitcher like the PUR PLUS, or move to reverse osmosis with the AquaTru Carafe. See how the jugs compare in our best water filter pitchers guide.
Check price on Amazon ›